Skip to main content
GOTHAM THRIFT NY

GOTHAM THRIFT NY

42K items sold
1.9K followers
Contact

Featured categories

Newly Listed

See all

  • Cuba TV by Simone Lueck (HC, 2011, Mark Batty)

    $9.99

  • Native Nations Vol. 1: Chiefs & Warriors (HC, 1996, 1st Ed)

    $6.99

  • When The Stars Align: Reflections on Astrology by Ray Grasse (SC, 2022, 1st Ed)

    $19.99

  • Florida's Changing Waters: A Beautiful World in Peril (HC, 2019) SEALED

    $29.99

  • Heart To Heart by the Dalai Lama and Patrick McDonnell (HC, 2023, 1st Ed)

    $11.99

  • Street Dogs by Traer Scott (HC, 2007, 1st Print) SIGNED by the Author

    $17.99

NEW ARRIVALS ADDED DAILY!

Check back daily!

Shop now
NEW ARRIVALS ADDED DAILY!

All items

Vintage DEATH OF SUPERMAN Collectors Set (White Bag) SEALED (#500) DC COMICS

$5.49

Vintage 1990s The Simpsons Home Sweet Home Plastic Sign NOS 11x8 FOX N4A

$8.99

Marvel Retro Red Iron Man Shirt Mens sz M NWT

$13.99

Lot of 11 Vintage 1970s/80s Wrestling Original Photos Feat. Sammartino, K.O etc.

$29.99

1988 Genesis West Comics Last of The Viking Heroes #6 Vintage

$5.99

REGULAR SHOW 1 HASTINGS KABOOM SUMMER BLAST PHANTOM Variant comic a2a182

$5.49

G.I. Joe #2 2009 Adam Hughes Cover B IDW Publishing Variant

$44.99

2x Elizabeth Arden Flawless Finish Sponge-on Cream Makeup Bronzed Beige 1 Tester

$9.99

Judge Dredd: Anderson, Psi-Division #1; IDW

$4.99

Twelve Reasons to Die #1 Third Eye Comics Variant comic n1d161

$14.99

Garfield (2012) #1 - Hastings Variant - Comic Book - From Kaboom Comics g1b5

$9.99

Cars 2 #1 The Story of The Movie in Comics Disney Comics Book 2011 Pixar Marvel

$5.99

Fantasy Master Raven FM-439 Stainless Steel Black Tactical Hunting Knife 15 1/2"

$14.99

Wolverine: Sabretooth By Joseph Loeb + Simone Bianchi (HC, Marvel) SEALED

$19.99

Vintage Calvin Klein Jeans Womens Blue Light Wash Mid Rise Denim Shorts Size 30

$32.99

Green Arrow #0 (October 1994, DC Comics) 1st Connor Hawke vintage

$8.49

Skylanders #0 Convention Variant IDW Granite State 2014

$21.99

Coalport Made In England Ming Rose Bone China, 3.5" Tea Cup

$19.99

Vintage Boy Scouts Of America Tan Map Design Bandana Ten Mile River Scout Camp

$29.99

Batman Adventures #3 DC Comics 1992 Joker Cover Fox TV Show vintage

$7.99

Marvel Mens Black Logo Long Sleeve Kangaroo Pockets Pullover Hoodie Size Medium

$21.99

Marvel Mens Purple Wolverine From The Wilderness X-Men Pullover T Shirt Size XLT

$13.99

the LEGACY of LUTHER STRODE #1 THIRD EYE variant Image comic book g5b55

$7.99

The Amazing Spider-Man #9 1st Electro Spiderman Collectible Series

$12.99

21st Century Archives The Petty Girl Premium Collectible Trading Cards Pack Of 8

$9.99

Funko Pop! Bullseye/Daredevil 2-Pack Marvel Collector Corps Exclusive Bobblehead

$29.99

Vintage Gold Mesh Blue Floral Sparkly Vest Womens sz 12 EUC

$24.99

Batman Dark Knight Triumphant #2 TPB 1986 FRANK MILLER DC Comics Vintage

$7.99

Yang #17 1986 Charlton Comic Book Copper Age

$6.99

Grooves Magazine Vol. 2 No. 2 February 1978 The Rolling Stones Includes Poster

$11.99

Zara Man Mens Red Slim Fit Long Sleeve Elbow Patch Polo Button Down Shirt Size L

$22.99

Bionic Commando Chain Of Command Comic Capcom video game

$24.99

Lacoste Mens Embroidered Logo Short Sleeve Collared 2 Button Polo Shirt Size 48

$29.99

Columbia Womens Salmon Pink Plaid Super Tamiami Outdoor Collared Button-Up Shirt

$24.99

Sweet Romance Magenta Rhinestone 3-Oval Design Hinge Bangle Bracelet

$24.99

Hollister Womens Blue Low Rise Light Wash 5 Pocket Denim Flared Jeans Size 3R

$21.99

2003 Mattel Polly Pocket Dare To Hair Totally Video Playset Accessories NIB

$29.99

Aladdin (DVD, 2004, 2-Disc Set, Special Edition - Gift Set)

$25.99

Cloth & Stone Womens Cream Linen Foldover Waist Band Wide Leg Dress Pant Size S

$53.99

Fruit of the Loom Gray Tropicana Perfect Orange Juice Shirt Mens L GUC

$29.99

Wonder Woman #0 DC 2nd Appearance of Artemis Brian Bolland DC 1994

$5.99

the AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #203 - 3rd Dazzler Appearance - Marvel 1980 Vintage!!

$12.99

Lacoste Rainbow Stripe Polo Shirt Childrens sz 8 GUC

$29.99

Boss Hugo Boss Mens Black Front Pleated Pockets Trousers Size 56

$34.99

X-Men Volume 2 #53 June 1996 False Fronts Newsstand Marvel Comic Book

$24.99

Lolita Jaca St Barth Ambrosia Perfume 100ml France New and Sealed N2

$24.99

Ben Sherman Black Military Coat Mens XS GUC

$39.99

Giuseppe Zanotti Womens Black Rhinestone Stiletto Strappy Snake Sandals Heels 40

$189.99
Items Per Page
See All

About us

We are a brick and mortar store based in Ridgewood, New York. If you can't visit our shop, come visit our eBay shop or follow us on Instagram @ GothamThriftNY . We carry a large variety of collectibles such as comic books, toys, music, DVD's, antiques and your one off kind of unique items.
Location: United StatesMember since: Sep 10, 2014Seller: gothamthriftny
Top Rated SellerGOTHAM THRIFT NY is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive2,497- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral13- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative6- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
4.9
Reasonable shipping cost
4.8
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (17,168)

9***a (783)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
I was very pleased to discover this eBay seller. He has a lot of great books and his reasonably priced books arrived as described and they were very neatly packed. Thanks.
j***r (81)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Awesome seller, fast shipper, fair price, well packed, good communication. I recommend this seller.
a***n (77)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
The item I received in the mail was what was advertised. It came carefully packaged fully protected. Seller did not take too long to ship out item. Also im happy to have received what i think is a rare item. A+ transaction. Thank you.
s***h (181)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Great seller. Items were as described. Fast shipping & very well packed. Good communication with A+ seller.
u***n- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Very nice record store and professionally protected and wrapped - Thanks for the gifts! Shipping was quick and prices are absolutely good value here!
h***2 (510)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Great seller...I had upfront questions and got a quick reply. My purchase arrived quickly and was securely packaged. Very pleased with my purchase. Thank you
See all feedback