Skip to main content
Johnny Cakes Collects

Johnny Cakes Collects

66 items sold
8 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Newly Listed

See all

  • 1996 Donruss #67 Mariano Rivera PSA 8 LOW POP

    $24.99

  • 1996 Topps #136 Hideo Nomo Rookie RC PSA 8

    $24.99

  • 1999 Topps #85 Derek Jeter PSA 8

    $19.99

  • 1994 Topps Finest #392 Don Mattingly PSA 8

    $39.99

  • 1995 Fleer Ultra #6 Ken Griffey Jr Gold Medallion Hitting Machines PSA 8 LOW POP

    $39.99

  • 1993 Marvel X-Men Series 2 Skybox Cards You-Pick

    $1.74 to $1.99

Buy 3, Get 1 Free

All Cards Under $5

Shop now
Buy 3, Get 1 Free

All items

The Simpsons 2001 Misadventures of Homer Sculpture Collection: Asleep on the Job

$28.99

1999 Topps #85 Derek Jeter PSA 8

$19.99

1993 Marvel X-Men Series 2 Skybox Cards You-Pick

$1.74 to $1.99

1995 Fleer Ultra #6 Ken Griffey Jr Gold Medallion Hitting Machines PSA 8 LOW POP

$39.99

Vintage 1990 TMNT Ninja Turtles The Movie Keychain

$12.99

1996 Donruss #67 Mariano Rivera PSA 8 LOW POP

$24.99

1991 TMNT Ninja Turtles Groundchuck Playmates Figure

$14.49

2009 Star Wars Legacy Collection Snowtrooper BD55 MOC

$31.99

1994 Marvel X-Men Fleer Ultra Cards You-Pick

$1.89 to $2.09Save up to 20% when you buy more

Vintage 1990s D.A.R.E. (DARE) Desk Organizer

$14.99

2005 Jeff Gordon #24 DuPont Daytona Raced Win Version 1/24 NASCAR Diecast

$52.99

2000 Burger King Dragon Ball Z Goku Gold and Silver Figure

$14.99

1996 Topps #136 Hideo Nomo Rookie RC PSA 8

$24.99

1994 Toy Biz Marvel Series 1 Iron Man Figure Only

$12.99

1997 Adventures Of Batman And Robin The Joker Figure by Kenner

$11.99

1991 Surge TMNT Ninja Turtles Raphael Rare Vintage Plastic Card

$4.99

1991 TMNT Ninja Turtles Zak The Neutrino Playmates Figure

$18.99

1994 Topps Finest #392 Don Mattingly PSA 8

$39.99

MAD Magazine #300 January 1991 "300th Issue"

$9.99

1992 Marvel X-Men Banshee ToyBiz Figure

$10.49

1996-1997 Tamagotchi New in Original Box Clear

$49.99

1989 Toy Biz Electronic Batmobile

$15.49

USS Enterprise Communicator Panel Door Chime 2011 Think Geek

$34.99

Vintage Fox 5 Kids Club Pin

$7.49

2023 Prizm Monopoly #75 Scoot Henderson Gold Millionaire Shimmer Rookie PSA 10

$124.99

1998 Martin Brodeur New Jersey Devils Starting Lineup MOC

$19.99Save up to 15% when you buy more

1960s Original Tinkertoy #136 by Spalding

$29.99

1994 Topps Finest #214 Rodney Hampton PSA 9 POP 1 (1 Higher)

$34.99

Jeopardy Video Game Lot Tiger Electronics NES Super Nintendo SNES

$49.99

1994 Bandai Power Rangers Red Ranger Thunderzord Firebird

$24.99

Vintage 1982 Eden Toys Paddington Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Teddy

$16.99

MAD Magazine Spring 1986 Super Special "Classic Flops"

$9.49

Rare Vintage 1990 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Hat Pin

$14.99

MAD Magazine #174 April 1975 "Death Wish"

$9.99

2015 Topps Chrome Refractor #148 Stefon Diggs PSA 10 Rookie RC

$74.99

1996 DC Comics Superman Figure by Kenner

$14.99

1991 TMNT Ninja Turtles Wyrm Playmates Figure

$15.99

1991 Hellraiser Mystery Puzzle Box Sealed by Screamin

$77.49

1991 TMNT Ninja Turtles Mutant Military Lieutenant Leo & Midshipman Mike

$24.00

2023 Prizm Monopoly #81 Victor Wembanyama Pink /149 PSA 9

$499.99

Mattel MUSCLE Figures You-Pick Kinnikuman

$8.99 to $13.99Save up to 16% when you buy more

1990 Bowman #50 Patrick Roy PSA 10 Low Pop

$124.99

1990 Bowman #7 Ed Belfour Rookie PSA 10

$124.99

1991 Pro Line Portraits #20 Eric Allen

$1.74

1991 TMNT Ninja Turtles Classic Rock Leo Playmates Figure

$19.99

Vintage Kenner Alien Figure Lot: Queen, Facehugger, Boar, Panther, Gorilla, Bull

$64.99

MAD Magazine USA Super Special Fall 1982 Advertising

$9.99

1996 Gargoyles Battle Goliath Figure Complete

$39.99
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Welcome!

Johnny Cakes here... I've been collecting on and off for the majority of my life. I usually stick to sports cards and memorabilia, or toys and pop culture items. I tend to gravitate towards the nostalgia of my childhood in the 90s but pretty much anything that catches my eye is a potential buy.

Unfortunately, a growing family has left little time for flea markets and card/toy shows so I've FINALLY taken the plunge and begun selling on eBay. By all means, reach out with any questions... I'm happy to respond and hopefully work together!

Cheers,
Johnny Cakes
Location: United StatesMember since: May 25, 2020Seller: johnnycakescollects

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive26- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral0- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative0- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
4.9
Reasonable shipping cost
5.0
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (26)

0***h (107)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Excellent communication and item was recieved as described. Would do business again!
0***h (107)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Excellent communication and item was recieved as described. Would do business again!
6***l (125)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Quick shipping, great packing and easy transaction! A+++. Thanks!
1***6 (134)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Hey thanks again, excellent condition. Great business, packaged efficiently and delivered fast.
o***s (4675)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
5-Star Seller!! Great Item!! Smooth & Easy Transaction!! Fast & Secure Shipping!! Thanks!!!
a***m (1)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Fast shipping. Packed very well and very carefully. Thank you!
See all feedback