Skip to main content
Misfit Collectibles

Misfit Collectibles

9.3K items sold
172 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Featured items

  • 1930s Tommy Toy 4" Red Beer Truck w/ Wood Barrels VTG Barclay Slush Mold

    $149.95

  • Diaclone 6-In-1 Constructicons KO Set 1983 Taiwan Pre Transformers G1 Devastator

    $800.00

  • Star Wars Princess Leia Organa Figure VTG 1977 Kenner Hong Kong Original Cape

    $74.95

  • WWE WrestleMania XX 20 Ticket Stub & Confetti MSG NYC WWF Eddie Guerrero History

    $500.00

  • Vintage 60s Batwoman Troll Doll w/ Red Hair, 3" Scandia House Batman Figure

    $69.95

  • Transformers G1 Aerialbot Fireflight Factory Sealed Unpunched VTG 1986 Hasbro

    $225.00

Holiday Collection

  • Barbie Holiday Mini Figure w/ Candy Cane Stripe Dress 4" Doll Stocking Stuffer

    $7.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

  • Disney Pixar Cars Wintertime Snowmobile Holiday Cruiser Diecast Stocking Stuffer

    $14.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

  • Lego Santa Claus Minifigure, Authentic Christmas Minifig

    $9.95

  • Pattern Plush Merry Bear, Manhattan Toy High Quality Holiday Stuffed Animal 12"

    $14.95

  • Tonka Metal Diecast Bodies Express Delivery Truck Holiday Edition 2015

    $7.95

  • Kurt Adler Dora The Explorer Hand Crafted Glass Holiday Ornaments Christmas Set

    $24.95

All items

SpongeBob Squarepants 8" Plush Patrick RARE 2020 Sponge On The Run Movie Toy

$14.95

Trolls World Tour Sparkle Dome Surprise Figure w/ Globe Snow Powder & Glitter

$4.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Marvel Iron Man Plush Avengers Endgame 8" Sitting Kuricha Bleacher Creatures NWT

$11.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

SpongeBob Squarepants 9" Plush RARE 2020 Sponge On The Run Movie Toy Authentic

$14.95

Disney Frozen Light Up Wand, 9" Blip Toy Party Favor, Anna Elsa Girls Accessory

$9.99

Minecraft Nano MetalFigs Jada Gift Set 20 Collectible Die-Cast Figures Series 6

$19.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Marvel Spider-Man Plush No Way Home 8" Sitting Kuricha Bleacher Creature Plushie

$11.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Lego Atlantis Deep Sea Striker 8076 Brand New Factory Sealed NIB

$49.95

Captain Marvel Plush Goose 8" Kuricha Bleacher Creatures Sitting Plushie Cat

$11.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Shaking Bobble Head Mouse Bank w/ Box 7" VTG 1950s "Mouce" No Cap MCI Flocked

$49.95

Lego Friends Chocolate Box & Flower Set #30411 Girls Christmas Stocking Stuffer

$5.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Disney Aladdin Genie Figure, Live Action Movie 4" Mini Doll

$4.99

Captain Marvel Plush 8" Kuricha Bleacher Creatures Avengers Sitting Plushie NWT

$11.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Barbie Holiday Mini Figure w/ Candy Cane Stripe Dress 4" Doll Stocking Stuffer

$7.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Marvel Avengers Pop Up Plush 3.5" Figure Set w/ Iron Man & Captain America

$5.95

Funko Marvel Venom Mystery Minis Bobble Head Figure NIB

$9.95Save up to 15% when you buy more

Marvel Black Panther Plush 8" Sitting Kuricha Bleacher Creatures Avengers NWT

$11.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Sim Life VTG PC Game 3.5" HD Disk, Windows IBM 1992, RARE Factory Sealed Big Box

$49.95

Transformers G1 Aerialbot Fireflight Factory Sealed Unpunched VTG 1986 Hasbro

$225.00

DC Justice League Wonder Woman Clip On Square Plush, 6" Keychain Figure

$4.95

ECW Ticket Stub Living Dangerously 1999 Final FTW Championship WWE WWF Wrestling

$100.00

Kenner M.A.S.K. Outlaw Venom Oil Tanker Pod Shell Missile Bomb Part VTG 1986

$19.95

Trolls World Tour Tiny Dancers Mini Figure & Glasses Blind Pack Stocking Stuffer

$1.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Maxx Action Helicopter Fire & Rescue Vehicle w/ Lights & Sound 5" Ages 5+ NEW

$12.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Lego City Stuntz Demolition Stunt Bike Set #60297 w/ Minifigure NIB

$5.95

Surprizamals Mama & Baby Mini Plush Animal Capsule Series 2 Stocking Stuffer

$9.95

Maxx Action Crane Construction Series Truck w/ Lights & Sound Rev Motor 5"

$12.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Remco Mantech Figure LaserTech Robot Warriors Set Vintage 1983 (Not Complete)

$24.95

Lego Mini Figure Santa Claus From City Christmas Advent Calendar Sealed Minifig

$7.95

Lego Disney Princess Beauty & The Beast Lumiere, Toys R Us Exclusive Promo Set

$14.99

Disney Cinderella Figure, Little Kingdom Snap-Ins Princess 3" Doll (Hasbro)

$9.99

Rare Lego Store Exclusive Duplo Brick Part Rockaway Bridgewater New Jersey NJ

$3.95

Lego Friends Pop Star Red Carpet Andrea Minifigure Set #30205

$5.95

PJ Masks Collectible Mini Figure In Valentines Day Heart Container Blind Pack #2

$2.98Save up to 20% when you buy more

Z-Bots Figure Tranzor w/ Scammer VTG 90s Galoob Micro Machines 8" Robot 1992 DMG

$29.95

WCW Wrestling Figure Lex Luger Toy Biz Ringmasters nWo VTG 90s WWE ECW

$12.95

Monster High Figure Lagoona Blue (Just Play 2015)

$9.99

Lil Woodzeez Bobblehead Blind Acorn Capsule (Green) Series 2 Figure, Easter Gift

$7.95

Marvel Avengers Hulk Clip On Square Plush, 6" Keychain Figure

$4.95

Holiday Woodlanders Fox Plush, Manhattan Toy High Quality Stuffed Animal 8"

$12.95

VTG Fisher Price S'getti Scatter Food Game RARE 90s Spaghetti Meatballs Toy NIB

$99.95

Ron & Fez Big A.S.S. Night Of Fights Ticket WNEW 102.7 FM Talk Radio Promo NYC

$99.95

Star Wars Geeki Tikis Yoda Ceramic Mug 12 Oz NIB Disney Collectible Holiday Gift

$24.95

WWE WrestleMania XX 20 Ticket Stub & Confetti MSG NYC WWF Eddie Guerrero History

$500.00

Vince McMahon WWF Wrestling Action Figure, Vintage 90s Jakks Pacific WWE BCA

$9.95

Valentines Day Surprise Heart Blind Pack w/ Plush Character

$9.95

Chuggington DieCast Wilson & Brewster Starter Set w/ Train Tracks (Damaged Box)

$34.95

Holiday Troll Doll Pencil Topper 1" PVC Mini Figure Green Hair Vintage 90s

$4.95
Items Per Page
See All

  • About us

    All toys welcome at Misfit Collectibles! Discover nostalgic goodness from the 70s, 80s, 90s and beyond. We buy vintage toys including Transformers, Star Wars action figures, G.I. Joe ARAH, WWF, and other pop culture favorites. If you're in New Jersey or the surrounding area, bring your collection to us for cash! We can also come to you and dig those old unwanted toys out of your home.

    This vintage toy shop is owned by a lifelong collector with 25+ years experience.

    Order pick up available on select listings by appointment only in Rockaway, NJ.
    Location: United StatesMember since: Jan 25, 1999Seller: misfit_collectibles
  • An error has occurred
    Play

About us

All toys welcome at Misfit Collectibles! Discover nostalgic goodness from the 70s, 80s, 90s and beyond. We buy vintage toys including Transformers, Star Wars action figures, G.I. Joe ARAH, WWF, and other pop culture favorites. If you're in New Jersey or the surrounding area, bring your collection to us for cash! We can also come to you and dig those old unwanted toys out of your home.

This vintage toy shop is owned by a lifelong collector with 25+ years experience.

Order pick up available on select listings by appointment only in Rockaway, NJ.
Location: United StatesMember since: Jan 25, 1999Seller: misfit_collectibles
Top Rated SellerMisfit Collectibles is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Store policies

Returns
Shipping

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive45- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral1- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative0- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.9
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (3,802)

e***0 (368)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item as Described, Just what was Needed, Good Price, Shipped Fast A+++++ Seller
n***m (313)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item as described. Great communication. Fast shipping. A+++++
s***b (26)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
The plush came on time, the communication was great. The plush came in fine condition with no problems at all. Item was shipped faster than date expected.
h***i (1473)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Excellent seller. Great transparency. Super fast shipping. A++++!!!!
_***p (17)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Shipped item quickly and the packaging for item was amazing super secure with a lot of bubble wrap and packing paper in a good size shipping box will definitely buy from this seller again
8***a (727)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Cute SpongeBob. Great seller with super fast shipping. Thank you.
See all feedback